Connect & Solve
Trade Q&A
What are the core definitions and essential differences between entrepot trade and barter trade?
or complex compliance issues.
clearance and fund security.
I am the head of a hardware tools export foreign trade company based in Shanghai. Last week, during a video call with a Southeast Asian customer to discuss a 5 million USD annual order, they suddenly proposed to cooperate using a combination of entrepot trade and barter trade, saying it could bypass their newly imposed 25% high tariff. I have only done general trade before and have no concept of these two models at all.
The more I checked online information, the more confused I got—some say it is legal and compliant, while others say it is suspected of smuggling. I haven't slept well for several days in a row: I don't want to miss this big order that can revitalize the production capacity in the second half of the year, but I am also afraid of crossing compliance red lines and having goods detained or fined by the customs, and worried about not getting back the cargo rights and funds. I hope you can explain clearly what entrepot trade and barter trade actually are from the aspects of definitions, compliance boundaries and risk hazards?
Eric ZhouYears of service：6Customer Rating：5.0
Senior Manager of Foreign Exchange & Tax RebatesStart a Chat
First，we need to expose common industry misconceptions: many practitioners mistakenly believe that entrepot trade is "forging certificates of origin to bypass tariffs"，and barter trade is "exchanging goods without compliance filing". Both of these perceptions may trigger fatal risks.
If you engage in the practice of forging certificates of origin，once the customs of the importing country detects abnormal origin through the traceability system，the goods will be directly detained. The demurrage and warehouse rent can reach 300-500 USD per day，and if not resolved within 15 days，the goods will be auctioned，the enterprise will also be included in the global customs blacklist，and will not be able to participate in any cross-border trade tender within 3 years. If barter trade is not filed with the customs in advance，it will be recognized as "smuggling without documents". While the goods are confiscated，the person in charge of the enterprise may face criminal liability of up to 3 years，and the domestic account will also be frozen.
Physical risk isolation measures need to achieve two points: first，choose neutral transit countries such as Singapore and Malaysia，complete the real transit storage and container swapping procedures，and obtain formal transit bills of lading，warehouse certificates and transit certificates of origin，second，barter trade needs to be filed in advance in the customs "cross-border barter management system"，clarifying the value，categories and delivery nodes of both parties.
Exclusive loss prevention tip: Agree with the compliance agency on third-party cargo right supervision，the agency shall hold the warehouse receipt during the cargo transit period until both parties complete the cargo right delivery，at the same time，purchase cross-border trade credit insurance to cover extreme risks such as customs detention，confiscation and cargo damage.
Lucas LiuYears of service：8Customer Rating：5.0
Senior Operations ConsultantStart a Chat
From the perspective of customs valuation and compliance, the core of entrepot trade is that "goods do not enter or exit the country". When declaring customs, three core documents must be submitted: the transit country's storage agreement, container swapping voucher and transit bill of lading, and the goods name, weight and shipping mark on the documents must be exactly the same, otherwise the customs will determine it as "falsely declaring trade mode", triggering deletion and re-declaration or even customs detention. Barter trade needs to complete "cross-border barter filing" before customs declaration.
When filing, the signed barter contract and cargo value assessment report of both parties must be submitted, and the cargo value error shall not exceed 5%, otherwise the customs will initiate the valuation dispute procedure, leading to customs clearance delay. In addition, the "trade mode" column of the entrepot trade customs declaration form shall be filled with "entrepot trade", and barter trade shall be filled with "barter trade", which shall not be confused, otherwise it will affect the subsequent foreign exchange receipt and payment and tax refund.
Jason WuYears of service：10Customer Rating：5.0
International Logistics & Supply Chain ManagerStart a Chat
From the perspective of international logistics path and cargo right control, entrepot trade needs to select ports with transit qualifications, such as Pasir Panjang Port in Singapore and Port Klang in Malaysia. These ports have higher efficiency in transit storage and container swapping, and can provide formal transit certificates. During transit, cargo rights need to be monitored throughout the process: take photos of the original container seal before swapping, and take photos of the new container seal and cargo inventory video after swapping to ensure that the goods are not replaced. The logistics path of barter trade needs to clarify the "two-way delivery nodes".
For example, within 30 days after our goods arrive at the other party's port, the other party's goods must arrive at our designated port. At the same time, select a negotiable sea bill of lading, so that in case of delivery delay, the cargo rights can be transferred by endorsement to reduce losses. In addition, entrepot trade needs to confirm the free storage period of the transit port in advance, which is generally 7-10 days. If it exceeds, apply for an extension in advance to avoid generating container detention fees.
Victor SunYears of service：5Customer Rating：5.0
Trade Risk Control ManagerStart a Chat
From the perspective of international tax planning, entrepot trade can enjoy the low tax rate policy of the transit country by setting up an offshore company in the transit country. For example, Singapore levies 17% corporate income tax on the profits of entrepot trade, but can enjoy the overseas profit exemption policy, and the actual tax rate can be as low as less than 5%. Barter trade needs to pay attention to tax accounting: the value of the goods of both parties shall be determined according to the fair market value.
If the fair value of one party's goods is higher than the agreed price, the excess part shall be treated as sales and value-added tax shall be paid. At the same time, submit the barter contract and cargo value assessment report when declaring tax to avoid being recognized as "related party transaction profit transfer" by the tax authority. In addition, the foreign exchange receipt and payment of entrepot trade shall be completed through offshore accounts to avoid exchange loss in domestic accounts directly, and can enjoy the VAT deferral policy to delay the payment of import value-added tax.
Grace WangYears of service：10Customer Rating：5.0
Senior Foreign Trade ConsultantStart a Chat
From the perspective of cross-border foreign exchange receipt and payment compliance, the foreign exchange receipt and payment of entrepot trade must comply with the regulation that "the interval between receipt and payment of the same transaction shall not exceed 90 days", and the difference between the receipt amount and the payment amount shall be controlled within 5%. Otherwise, the bank will list the transaction as a "suspicious transaction" and initiate an anti-money laundering investigation. If there is a difference in the foreign exchange receipt and payment of barter trade, it shall be settled through formal channels, and shall not be transferred privately through offshore accounts.
Otherwise, it will be included in the "foreign exchange receipt and payment abnormal list" by the State Administration of Foreign Exchange, and the enterprise's cross-border foreign exchange receipt and payment authority will be suspended. In addition, the SWIFT message of entrepot trade shall be marked with "ENTREPOT TRADE", and barter trade shall be marked with "BARTER TRADE", and the content of the message must be consistent with the customs declaration form and contract to avoid inconsistency between the message and the documents.
Andy GuoYears of service：3Customer Rating：5.0
Supply Chain Management ExpertStart a Chat
From the perspective of international trade legal protection, the entrepot trade contract needs to clarify the responsibilities of the transit party. For example, the transit party shall ensure the safety of the goods during the transit period. If cargo damage or loss occurs, the transit party shall compensate at 120% of the fair value of the goods.
The barter trade contract needs to add a "force majeure fallback clause", clarifying that if one party is unable to deliver the goods due to customs detention or policy changes, it shall notify the other party within 7 days and provide relevant proof, otherwise it shall pay a penalty equivalent to 10% of the total contract amount. In addition, entrepot trade requires the transit party to provide a letter of indemnity (LOI) to ensure the compliance of the transit process; barter trade needs to conduct intellectual property record search on the other party's goods to avoid customs detention due to suspected infringement of the goods.
Linda GaoYears of service：7Customer Rating：5.0
Documentation SupervisorStart a Chat
From the perspective of export tax refund compliance, entrepot trade does not fall within the scope of export tax refund, and export tax refund shall not be declared. If it is declared by mistake, the tax authority will initiate a letter of inquiry procedure, requiring the submission of transit documents, storage agreements and other materials. If it cannot be provided, the refunded tax will be recovered and a fine of 0.5-1 times will be imposed.
If the exported goods of barter trade meet the tax refund conditions, the tax refund shall be declared within 90 days after customs declaration and export. When declaring, documents such as barter contract, cargo value assessment report, customs declaration form and bill of lading must be submitted, and the "four-stream consistency" (contract flow, cargo flow, capital flow and invoice flow) of the documents must be strictly matched. Otherwise, it will be recognized as "false tax refund" by the tax authority, and the enterprise's tax refund authority will be suspended. In addition, if the imported goods of barter trade are used for domestic sales, import value-added tax and tariffs shall be paid, and the export tax refund shall not be deducted.