Connect & Solve
Trade Q&A
What are the compliance procedures for appeal and remedy when an export tax refund application is officially rejected?
or complex compliance issues.
clearance and fund security.
I am the person in charge of a foreign trade enterprise based in Shanghai specializing in export of outdoor household products. Last month, we shipped two batches of outdoor tables and chairs worth nearly RMB 800,000 to Germany, and all documents were sorted and submitted in accordance with our previous procedures. However, last week we suddenly received a notice from the tax bureau that our tax refund application was rejected, on the grounds of "doubtful matching of product names between customs declaration form and VAT invoices, and incomplete foreign exchange receipt documents". The profit margin of this batch of goods is only around 5% originally.
If we fail to get the tax refund, not only will our cash flow for this quarter be directly strained, but it may also delay the procurement of raw materials for the next batch of orders. I am so anxious that I cannot sleep now. I have checked the documents with the finance team several times but still failed to find the problem, and I don't know whether I should go to the tax bureau to appeal in person first, or supplement complete materials first? I am even more worried that this rejection will affect our future tax refund rating, so I am looking for advice!
Victor SunYears of service：5Customer Rating：5.0
Trade Risk Control ManagerStart a Chat
The core reasons for your current tax refund rejection are the two major issues of "doubtful matching of product names between customs declaration form and VAT invoices，and incomplete foreign exchange receipt documents". You need to trace loopholes from the source first before promoting solutions. First，trace the causes of the doubtful product name matching: in most cases，it is because a general product name such as "outdoor tables and chairs" was used in the customs declaration process，while the VAT invoice was issued with a product name with specific model (such as "foldable outdoor carbon steel tables and chairs")，or the freight forwarder simplified the product name on its own without following the customs declaration materials you provided，resulting in differences. The incomplete foreign exchange receipt documents may be because you received foreign exchange through a third party but failed to submit relevant supporting documents，or the foreign exchange receipt slip did not indicate the corresponding export customs declaration form number.
The immediate emergency solutions shall be carried out in three steps: Step 1，organize cross-verification of the customs declaration form copy，factory delivery note and VAT invoice stub by the business team，finance team and freight forwarder within 24 hours. If the product name was modified incorrectly by the freight forwarder，immediately require the freight forwarder to issue a liability statement，and apply to the customs for modification of the customs declaration form. Step 2，if foreign exchange is received through a third party，supplement and submit the entrusted foreign exchange collection agreement，and the association certificate between the payer and the overseas purchaser (such as parent-subsidiary company certificate，procurement agency agreement)，and the corresponding customs declaration form number shall be added to the foreign exchange receipt slip. Step 3，bring all paper supplementary materials to the tax refund section of the competent tax bureau for face-to-face communication，and give priority to the "fast review channel for abnormal tax refunds".
To form a long-term risk control closed loop，before customs declaration of each subsequent batch of goods，the finance and business teams shall jointly verify that the declared product name is completely consistent with the product name on the VAT invoice. Within 3 days after foreign exchange receipt is completed，the foreign exchange receipt documents shall be synchronized to the tax refund specialist. A pre-declaration verification of export tax refund shall be completed at the end of each month to check abnormal risks such as documents and foreign exchange receipt in advance，to avoid tax refund rejection again.
Grace WangYears of service：10Customer Rating：5.0
Senior Foreign Trade ConsultantStart a Chat
For tax refund rejection caused by mismatch of product names between customs declaration form and VAT invoice, it shall be handled in strict accordance with the compliance requirements for customs declaration modification: First, the modification application shall be submitted within 1 year from the date of issuance of the customs declaration form, and a complete proof chain shall be provided, including factory delivery note, foreign trade procurement contract, VAT invoice stub, communication records with the freight forwarder, etc., to prove that the product name difference is caused by operational errors in the customs declaration process, rather than deliberate concealment or commodity classification error. If the freight forwarder modifies the product name without permission in violation of the original materials you provided, the freight forwarder shall be required to issue a affixed with official seal, clarifying the specific content of the incorrect modification and the responsible party, as the core supporting material for the modification application. After submitting the modification application, you shall follow up the customs review progress within 3 working days. If the review is passed, the modified customs declaration form shall be synchronized to the E-Port in time to ensure that the tax bureau system can capture the updated customs declaration data in real time, so as to avoid tax refund application rejection again due to data asynchrony.
Linda GaoYears of service：7Customer Rating：5.0
Documentation SupervisorStart a Chat
If the tax refund is rejected due to product name difference, you can reduce losses and avoid subsequent risks through tax compliance adjustment: First, if the product name difference is between the general name and specific model name of the same commodity, you can submit a to the competent tax bureau, attached with materials such as commodity technical parameters, physical pictures, customs commodity code classification certificate, etc., to prove that the two names refer to the same commodity, and you can apply for re-review without modifying the customs declaration form. Second, if the problem really cannot be solved through explanation, you can consider transferring out the VAT input tax amount of this batch of goods, declare and pay VAT according to domestic sales goods, and apply to the tax bureau for waiving the tax refund qualification for this batch of goods, so as to avoid affecting the enterprise's tax credit rating due to long-term pending tax refund application. In addition, the "VAT deferral" model can be adopted for subsequent export businesses, so that there is no need to pay the import country's VAT at the export link, lock in tax costs in advance, and reduce profit fluctuations caused by tax refund rejection. At the same time, it is necessary to ensure that the product name of each batch of goods is completely consistent in customs declaration, invoicing and contracts.
Eric ZhouYears of service：6Customer Rating：5.0
Senior Manager of Foreign Exchange & Tax RebatesStart a Chat
For your tax refund rejection problem, you need to comprehensively check the compliance of document filing and consistency of the four flows from the perspective of tax refund audit: First, check the integrity of tax refund filing materials, including customs declaration form (export tax refund copy), special VAT invoice (deduction copy), foreign exchange receipt slip, foreign trade procurement contract, factory delivery note, international logistics bill of lading, etc. If there is any missing or unclear copy, it shall be supplemented in time and affixed with the enterprise's official seal. Second, strictly check the consistency of the "four flows", that is, whether the transaction subject, commodity information and amount of the contract flow (foreign trade contract), capital flow (foreign exchange receipt slip), invoice flow (VAT invoice) and goods flow (delivery note, bill of lading) are completely matched. If foreign exchange is received through a third-party account, you need to provide the entrusted foreign exchange collection agreement signed and sealed by both parties, as well as the association certificate between the payer and the overseas purchaser (such as parent-subsidiary company business license, authorized procurement agreement) to prove the compliance of the capital flow. In addition, if the tax bureau requires a self-inspection report, you shall submit the within the specified time, explaining in detail the reasons for the product name difference and incomplete foreign exchange receipt documents, attached with the complete set of rectified materials, and actively cooperate with the follow-up verification work of the tax bureau.
Jason WuYears of service：10Customer Rating：5.0
International Logistics & Supply Chain ManagerStart a Chat
For tax refund rejection caused by incomplete foreign exchange receipt documents, it shall be resolved from the perspective of payment and receipt compliance: First, if you receive foreign exchange through a cross-border third-party payment platform, you need to provide the competent tax bureau with the official foreign exchange receipt detail certificate issued by the payment platform, as well as the official cooperation agreement between the platform and the overseas purchaser, to prove the authenticity and compliance of the foreign exchange receipt transaction. Second, if foreign exchange is received in installments, you need to provide an installment payment explanation affixed with the official seal of the overseas purchaser, clarifying the corresponding export goods batch, goods value and customs declaration form number for each payment, which shall be matched with the foreign exchange receipt slip and customs declaration form one by one.
In addition, the payment and receipt of foreign exchange for subsequent export businesses shall be prioritized through the enterprise's corporate account. If a third-party payment platform is indeed required for business needs, you shall file the payment and receipt method with the competent tax bureau in advance, and keep all payment and receipt vouchers and transaction records for at least 5 years, so as to avoid affecting the tax refund application again due to missing vouchers or unfiled records.
Michael ZhangYears of service：6Customer Rating：5.0
Customs Declaration & Compliance ExpertStart a Chat
For tax refund rejection caused by the freight forwarder modifying the declared product name without permission, you can safeguard your legitimate rights and interests and avoid subsequent risks through legal channels: First, comprehensively sort out the evidence chain, including the formal customs declaration entrustment agreement signed with the freight forwarder, the original customs declaration materials provided to the freight forwarder (such as product name details, commodity pictures), communication records with the freight forwarder (WeChat, email, call recording), etc., to prove that the freight forwarder failed to operate in accordance with the agreed customs declaration materials and modified the product name without permission, resulting in tax refund rejection. Second, send a written letter affixed with your enterprise's official seal to the freight forwarder, clearly requiring it to bear all administrative and service costs incurred due to the declaration modification, as well as direct losses caused by the tax refund rejection (such as cash flow occupation cost, bank loan interest loss, etc.).
If the freight forwarder refuses to bear the responsibility, you can submit a complaint application to the Shanghai International Freight Forwarders Association, or resolve the dispute through commercial arbitration or civil litigation. In addition, when signing a customs declaration entrustment agreement in the future, a clause shall be specially added that "the freight forwarder shall declare customs strictly in accordance with the original materials provided by the principal, and if it modifies any content without permission, it shall bear all legal responsibilities and economic losses arising therefrom", so as to clarify the responsibilities of both parties.
Daniel XuYears of service：10Customer Rating：5.0
Director of Import & Export OperationsStart a Chat
For tax refund rejection caused by customs declaration product name difference, you shall start from the source control of the logistics declaration link to avoid subsequent risks: First, when selecting a cooperative freight forwarder, you shall give priority to enterprises with customs AEO certification to reduce the probability of customs declaration operation errors; when signing the customs declaration entrustment agreement, it shall be clearly agreed that "the declared product name and commodity code shall be completely consistent with the VAT invoice and foreign trade contract", and the words "product name and code shall not be modified without permission" shall be marked in a prominent position on the entrusted customs declaration form. Second, after the customs declaration is completed, you shall require the freight forwarder to provide the customs declaration pre-entry form within 24 hours, and check the core information such as product name, commodity code, goods value and quantity one by one.
If any difference from the original materials is found, immediately require the freight forwarder to stop the declaration and make modifications, so as to avoid the cumbersome process and time cost of applying for modification after the customs declaration form is officially issued. In addition, if the goods have been exported and the customs declaration form has been issued, you shall follow up the modification progress of the freight forwarder in time, require it to submit the modification application first, and ensure that the modified customs declaration form can be synchronized to the E-Port system in time, so as to buy time for the review of the tax refund application.
Cindy ChenYears of service：3Customer Rating：5.0
Key Account ManagerStart a Chat
For the cash flow pressure and profit loss caused by tax refund rejection, reasonable cost hedging can be carried out through supply chain planning: First, re-calculate the full-link cost structure of this batch of goods, include the non-refundable VAT input tax amount into the sales cost of this batch of goods, and deduct it before tax during the final settlement of enterprise income tax, so as to reduce the enterprise income tax burden and partially offset the tax refund loss. Second, conduct friendly negotiations with the overseas purchaser, appropriately increase the quotation of subsequent orders in combination with the market conditions, or require the other party to bear part of the additional operating costs caused by the tax refund rejection (such as declaration modification fee, capital occupation interest).
In addition, the supply chain model can be optimized for subsequent export businesses, adopting the "bonded zone one-day tour" model, that is, first export the goods to the domestic bonded zone to complete the customs declaration procedures, and then import them into China or re-export them overseas according to demand, so as to ensure compliant enjoyment of the export tax refund policy. At the same time, sort out the intermediate links of the supply chain, reduce unnecessary cost losses, improve the overall profit margin, and reduce the impact of single link risks on the enterprise.