Connect & Solve
Trade Q&A
Who exactly is the legal payment subject for various taxes such as customs duties and VAT within the scope of agency import business?
or complex compliance issues.
clearance and fund security.
I am a small mechanical and electrical equipment dealer in Shanghai. Last month, I signed an agency import agreement with Zhongshen to import a batch of precision bearings from Germany. The contract stipulates that "all taxes such as customs duties and VAT shall be borne by our side". But yesterday, the customs broker suddenly asked me to transfer the tax funds to their company account for payment on our behalf.
However, I heard from peers that the agency company is the legal payment subject. I am completely confused now! I also heard last week that another freight forwarder's client had a dispute over the tax payment subject, resulting in 12 days of port detention and over 30,000 yuan in detention fees and overdue fines.
I am particularly anxious now, fearing that I will fall into a trap: who should legally pay these taxes? Can the contract terms take precedence over legal requirements? If I transfer the funds to the agency company for payment on their behalf, what if they misappropriate the funds and cause overdue tax payment and customs detention? What documents do I need to retain to avoid risks?
Linda GaoYears of service：7Customer Rating：5.0
Documentation SupervisorStart a Chat
First，two common industry misconceptions are exposed: one is the misunderstanding that if the contract stipulates "the entrusting party shall bear the taxes"，the entrusting party needs to pay the taxes directly to the customs，the other is the belief that the agency company，as the customs declaration operator，must bear all tax payment responsibilities. Both of these perceptions will directly lead to compliance risks.
If the payment subject is confused in operation，such as the entrusting party transferring taxes to a non-official agency account，or the agency failing to pay the taxes on time as agreed，it will directly trigger customs overdue fines. If the overdue period exceeds 15 days，the goods will be moved to the detention port area，resulting in detention fees and container detention fees of hundreds of yuan per container per day. In severe cases，the goods will be detained by the customs. If the goods are detained for a long time，they may lose market value due to moisture or depreciation，and even be auctioned according to law，causing irreversible economic losses to the entrusting party.
Two points need to be implemented for physical risk isolation: first，clarify that the legal payment subject is the foreign trade agency company (the operating unit on the customs declaration form is the agency)，but the tax cost can be stipulated to be borne by the entrusting party in the contract. Such an agreement only binds the two parties and does not affect the customs' recognition of the legal subject，second，all tax funds must be transferred to the agency company's special import tax payment account，and private accounts or non-designated accounts are strictly prohibited.
Exclusive loss prevention tips: require the agency to issue a customs tax payment notice before each payment，request the scanned copy of the customs tax payment certificate after transferring the funds and retain the original copy. At the same time，explicitly stipulate in the contract that "if the agency fails to pay the taxes on time and in full，all detention fees，overdue fines and customs detention losses caused thereby shall be borne by the agency"，so as to lock in risks from the contract level.
Jason WuYears of service：10Customer Rating：5.0
International Logistics & Supply Chain ManagerStart a Chat
From the perspective of customs declaration compliance, in agency import business, the "operating unit" on the customs declaration form is the foreign trade agency company. According to the Customs Law of the People's Republic of China, the operating unit is the legal tax payment obligor. It should be noted that if the entrusting party has the right to import and export, it can apply for dual-head customs declaration, in which case the entrusting party and the agency company are joint payment subjects, but the "dual-head" must be marked on the customs declaration form in advance, and a formal power of attorney must be submitted to the customs.
If the dual-head mark is not made, the customs will only recognize the agency company as the sole payment subject. At this time, if the entrusting party pays the taxes directly, there will be a situation where the taxes cannot be verified and written off, and a refund process is required, which takes at least 15-20 days, seriously affecting the customs clearance efficiency of the goods. In addition, if the agency company fails to pay the taxes on time, the customs will record the dishonesty record in its customs credit rating, leading to a surge in the inspection rate of all subsequent customs declaration businesses, and even being downgraded to a default enterprise, directly affecting the customs clearance speed of the entrusting party's goods.
Cindy ChenYears of service：3Customer Rating：5.0
Key Account ManagerStart a Chat
From the perspective of the entire international logistics chain, the timeliness of tax payment directly determines the efficiency of goods' in-port circulation. If the tax payment is overdue due to unclear payment subject, the goods will be moved from the ordinary port area to the detention port area by the terminal, resulting in detention fees of 300-500 yuan per container per day.
If the overdue period exceeds 30 days, some ports will transfer the goods to the customs supervision warehouse, and the fee will double to 600-1000 yuan per container per day. In addition, if the agency company is listed on the dishonesty list by the customs due to overdue tax payment, all goods entrusted by it will be subject to targeted inspection, with the inspection rate rising from the conventional 5% to 100%, extending the port detention time by another 3-7 days.
To avoid such risks, the entrusting party needs to confirm the tax amount and payment path 72 hours before the goods arrive at the port, and require the agency to provide a "tax payment timeliness commitment letter", clearly stating that if the tax payment is not completed within 48 hours after the goods arrive at the port, all additional logistics costs shall be borne by the agency. At the same time, the entrusting party can require the freight forwarder to endorse the bill of lading to its own name, ensuring the right to dispose of the goods in case of a tax dispute.
Evelyn LiYears of service：3Customer Rating：5.0
Cross-border Compliance SupervisorStart a Chat
From the perspective of cross-border tax planning, import tax payment can optimize capital costs through the import VAT deferral policy. At present, the Shanghai port has fully implemented import VAT deferral, that is, the entrusting party does not need to pay the import VAT when clearing customs, but can deduct it in the subsequent VAT declaration. This can reduce capital occupation costs by about 13%-17% (corresponding to the import VAT rate). It should be noted that the applicant for VAT deferral is the foreign trade agency company, which needs to submit the "Import VAT Deferred Tax Payment Application Record Form" to the customs in advance, and the entrusting party must be a general VAT taxpayer with the qualification of input tax deduction.
If the entrusting party is a small-scale taxpayer, it cannot enjoy the VAT deferral policy and needs to pay the full import VAT when clearing customs. At this time, it is necessary to explicitly stipulate in the contract that the agency company shall provide the tax payment certificate within 3 working days after payment, so as to be included in cost accounting. In addition, if the entrusting party and the agency company are affiliated enterprises, it is necessary to ensure that the tax pricing conforms to the arm's length principle to avoid triggering tax audits.
Michael ZhangYears of service：6Customer Rating：5.0
Customs Declaration & Compliance ExpertStart a Chat
From the perspective of cross-border payment and settlement compliance, the funds for agency import tax payment must strictly comply with foreign exchange management regulations. When the entrusting party pays taxes to the agency company, it shall clearly indicate "payment of customs duties/VAT for XX batch of imported goods" in the transfer remarks, and the funds shall be transferred from the entrusting party's official corporate account, and private account transfers are strictly prohibited. Otherwise, it will be identified as "illegal foreign exchange arbitrage" by the State Administration of Foreign Exchange, triggering foreign exchange audits and facing penalties such as fines.
In addition, if the agency company uses the Cross-border Interbank Payment System (CIPS) to pay taxes in RMB, it is necessary to ensure that the currency of the customs declaration form is consistent with the payment currency; if the declaration is in foreign currency, foreign exchange purchase shall be carried out first before payment, and the agency shall provide the agency import agreement, customs declaration pre-entry form and other documents to the bank when purchasing foreign exchange. If the entrusting party needs to pay taxes in foreign exchange, it needs to complete the "import payment registration" record in advance, otherwise the foreign exchange payment cannot be completed, leading to overdue tax payment.
Victor SunYears of service：5Customer Rating：5.0
Trade Risk Control ManagerStart a Chat
From the perspective of international trade law, the liability division of agency import tax payment must be clearly agreed through contract terms, and the agreement shall not violate mandatory legal provisions. According to the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China, the agreement on tax burden in the power of attorney contract only binds the entrusting party and the agency company, and cannot counter the legal requirements of the customs. That is, no matter how the contract is agreed, the customs will only recognize the operating unit (agency company) on the customs declaration form as the legal payment subject.
Therefore, two points need to be clearly stipulated in the contract: first, "the entrusting party shall bear all tax costs of this import of goods, and the agency company shall be responsible for paying them on behalf"; second, "if the agency company fails to pay the taxes on time and in full, all overdue fines, detention fees, customs detention losses and indirect losses caused by customs dishonesty records shall be borne by the agency company". In addition, it is necessary to agree that the agency company shall provide the customs tax payment certificate within 3 working days after paying the taxes, and if it fails to provide it, the entrusting party has the right to refuse to pay subsequent agency fees.
Andy GuoYears of service：3Customer Rating：5.0
Supply Chain Management ExpertStart a Chat
From the perspective of customs on-site inspection, the clarity of the tax payment subject will directly affect the efficiency of abnormal handling after inspection. If the customs determines that the declared price of the goods is too low during inspection and requires supplementary payment of differential taxes, the legal supplementary payment subject is the agency company.
However, if the contract stipulates that the cost shall be borne by the entrusting party, the agency company shall notify the entrusting party of the supplementary payment within 24 hours, otherwise it will lead to detention during inspection and additional inspection service fees and detention fees. In addition, if the goods are subject to legal inspection, the inspection shall be completed before paying the taxes. If the agency company fails to complete the inspection in time, resulting in overdue tax payment, it will be fined 0.5%-3% of the goods' value by the customs.
To avoid such risks, the entrusting party needs to request the agency company to provide the scanned copies of the commodity inspection clearance certificate and the tax payment notice 72 hours before the goods arrive at the port, and pay the taxes only after confirming that they are correct. If there is a need for supplementary tax payment during on-site inspection, it is necessary to require the agency to provide the "price query notice" issued by the customs, and pay the differential amount after verification.
Kevin LinYears of service：4Customer Rating：5.0
Trade Solutions ManagerStart a Chat
From the perspective of supply chain cost accounting, the choice of agency import tax payment subject will affect the overall supply chain cost and capital turnover rate. If the agency company pays the taxes on behalf, the entrusting party needs to include the tax cost in the total import cost, including customs duties, VAT, consumption tax (if any) and agency service fees for tax payment (usually 0.5%-1% of the tax amount).
If the entrusting party has the right to import and export, choosing dual-head customs declaration as the joint payment subject can directly include the import VAT in the input tax deduction, without going through the agency company to transfer the certificate, saving the agency's transfer service fees and time costs. In addition, adopting the import VAT deferral policy, the entrusting party does not need to advance the import VAT in advance, and can use the funds for inventory procurement, increasing the capital turnover rate by about 20%-30%. Therefore, the entrusting party needs to choose the optimal model based on whether it has the right to import and export, financial status and other factors.
Lucas LiuYears of service：8Customer Rating：5.0
Senior Operations ConsultantStart a Chat
From the perspective of export tax rebate compliance audit, the customs tax payment certificate for agency import tax payment is the core filing document for the entrusting party to handle export tax rebates subsequently. If the entrusting party is a production-oriented export enterprise, and the imported goods are used for the production of export products, the paid import VAT can be used as input tax deduction, or used as the basis for cost accounting when handling export tax rebates.
At this time, the entrusting party needs to ensure that the goods name, specification and quantity on the customs tax payment certificate provided by the agency company are completely consistent with the goods information on the export customs declaration form, otherwise the tax authorities will identify it as inconsistent documents, and the export tax rebate cannot be handled, with losses up to 13%-17% of the goods' value. In addition, the entrusting party needs to obtain the tax payment certificate within the export tax rebate declaration period (before the deadline for VAT declaration in April of the year after the goods are declared for export), otherwise the tax rebate declaration time will be missed. The tax payment certificate shall be included in the export tax rebate document filing directory and retained for at least 10 years.