Can the Importer and Foreign Trade Agent Be the Same Company? What Customs Supervision Risks Will It Cause?

Resolved
SERVICE
TRACKING NO. 20261117 / GLOBAL Zhongshen Trade · 23+ Years of Expert Trade Agency
Trade Challenges?
No import/export license, customs delays,
or complex compliance issues.
Our Solution
One-stop full-chain agency: ensure efficient
clearance and fund security.
Cost OptimizationUrgent ClearanceGlobal ResourcesCompliant Rebates

I am a new employee who has only been in charge of the company's import business for 3 months. Last week, when handling the import of a batch of high-precision mechanical equipment from Germany, my boss suddenly proposed that our affiliated foreign trade subsidiary should act as both the importer and the agent, saying that it can save service fees in intermediate links and speed up document circulation.

However, I saw in the industry exchange group before that such entity identity is easily identified as illegal by customs. Last week, a peer even encountered cargo detention and port delay due to this problem, with storage and container detention charges soaring to more than 2,000 yuan per day.

I am very anxious now: I am afraid that violating the boss's arrangement will affect my performance assessment, and I am also afraid that I will be held responsible if risks really occur. I want to ask for detailed advice: Can the importer and agent really be the same company? What hidden risks are there? If it is allowed, how to operate to ensure compliance?

Expert Insights

Expert Q&A

Jason Wu
Jason WuYears of service:10Customer Rating:5.0

International Logistics & Supply Chain ManagerStart a Chat

First of all,we need to expose a common industry misunderstanding: many enterprises mistakenly believe that the importer and agent can be the same entity,but in fact they confuse the subject positioning of foreign trade agency -- the agent is the entrusted subject to perform import operations,while the importer is the subject of cargo ownership and foreign exchange payment. If the two entities are identical,it is easy to be identified as "fake agency" by customs,suspected of evading supervision.

If this misunderstanding is ignored,it will trigger a chain of negative reactions: customs will launch value verification,suspecting that there is a connected transaction to transfer profits,which directly leads to cargo detention,resulting in thousands of yuan of port detention and container detention charges per day,if licenses such as mechanical and electrical import license or endangered species import permit are involved,it will also be identified as import without license,facing a fine of less than 5% of the declared cargo value,and even affecting the enterprise's customs credit rating,and the inspection ratio of subsequent import business will be increased to more than 30%.

Physical risk isolation measures: Even for parent and subsidiary companies,it is necessary to sign a formal import agency agreement to clarify agency fees,cargo ownership,division of rights and responsibilities,ensure consistency of four streams (contract,fund,document,cargo flow),and establish separate financial accounts for agency business,which are completely isolated from import business accounts.

Exclusive loss prevention tips: 5 working days before customs declaration,submit the Explanatory Statement on Import Agency to the local customs,and attach the equity relationship certificate of parent and subsidiary companies and the scanned copy of the agency agreement for filing in advance,if encountering customs verification,provide the Arm's Length Principle Certificate issued by a third-party audit institution at the first time,which can greatly reduce the verification risk.

Reference: Full Process Analysis of EU Export Agency: Practical Guide from Documentation to Tax Rebate
Linda Gao
Linda GaoYears of service:7Customer Rating:5.0

Documentation SupervisorStart a Chat

From the perspective of customs valuation and declaration compliance, if the importer and agent are the same company, it is necessary to focus on the filling rules of "declaring entity" and "consignee entity" on the customs declaration form. According to the latest regulations of the General Administration of Customs in 2026, the declaring entity shall be the subject that actually signs the import contract and is responsible for foreign exchange payment, and the consignee entity shall be the subject that actually uses the goods.

If the two are identical and marked as import agency, the customs will automatically trigger connected transaction verification, requiring the provision of agency agreement, fee settlement voucher, cargo ownership transfer certificate and other materials. If complete materials cannot be provided, it will be determined as false declaration, facing cargo detention, deletion and re-submission of customs declaration form, and even a fine of less than 5% of the declared cargo value. In addition, when it comes to the import of duty-reduced or exempted goods, the identity of entities will directly lead to the invalidation of duty reduction and exemption qualification, and full tax shall be paid retroactively.

Evelyn Li
Evelyn LiYears of service:3Customer Rating:5.0

Cross-border Compliance SupervisorStart a Chat

From the perspective of international logistics cargo right control and path optimization, if the importer and agent are the same company, it is necessary to focus on the issuance and endorsement of the bill of lading. Usually in the import agency mode, the bill of lading should be titled to the agent, and then endorsed and transferred to the importer. However, when the entities are identical, the bill of lading title is consistent with the consignee, which is easily identified as "no agency demand" by the shipping company, canceling the original logistics rate discount for agents, leading to a 5%-10% increase in sea freight and space booking costs.

In addition, if the goods encounter exceptions such as container rolling or space explosion at the transshipment port, due to the identity of entities, it is impossible to arrange space preferentially through the agent's channel, and the port detention risk will increase by more than 30%. It is recommended to clearly mark "self-operated import agency" when entrusting logistics, and sign an exclusive logistics agreement with the shipping company in advance to lock space and rate.

Grace Wang
Grace WangYears of service:10Customer Rating:5.0

Senior Foreign Trade ConsultantStart a Chat

From the perspective of cross-border tax planning and compliance, when the importer and agent are the same company, it is necessary to guard against the risk of connected transaction pricing transfer. According to the latest regulations of the State Taxation Administration on cross-border connected transactions in 2026, if the same entity plays the roles of both agent and importer at the same time, the pricing of agency fees shall comply with the arm's length principle, that is, it shall be consistent with the agency rate of unrelated third parties, and the floating range shall not exceed 10%.

If the agency rate is too high or too low, it will be determined by the tax authority as profit transfer, requiring retroactive payment of enterprise income tax, value-added tax and late fees. For import business involving VAT deferment, the deferment qualification will also be cancelled, and full import VAT shall be paid at one time. It is recommended to submit the connected transaction pricing filing form to the tax authority in advance, and conduct arm's length principle audit every year.

Eric Zhou
Eric ZhouYears of service:6Customer Rating:5.0

Senior Manager of Foreign Exchange & Tax RebatesStart a Chat

From the perspective of cross-border receipt and payment compliance, when the importer and agent are the same company, it is necessary to strictly abide by the filling specifications of CIPS (Cross-border Interbank Payment System) RMB cross-border payment and SWIFT messages. According to the regulations of the State Administration of Foreign Exchange in 2026, under the import agency mode, the foreign exchange payment subject shall be the agent. If it is the same as the importer, it is necessary to clearly mark "self-operated import agency" in the payment message, and attach the electronic scanned copies of the agency agreement and import contract.

If the marking is not clear, the foreign exchange bureau will trigger receipt and payment verification, suspend the enterprise's foreign exchange payment authority, resulting in the failure to pay the payment in time, and triggering breach of contract claims from overseas suppliers. In addition, if it involves receipt and payment through offshore accounts, the identity of entities will be identified as "self-buying and self-selling", facing the risk of offshore account freezing.

Kevin Lin
Kevin LinYears of service:4Customer Rating:5.0

Trade Solutions ManagerStart a Chat

From the perspective of international trade legal risk avoidance, when the importer and agent are the same company, it is necessary to improve the signing and retention of internal legal documents. Even for different departments of the same entity, it is necessary to sign a formal import agency agreement to clarify agency authority, cargo ownership, fee settlement method, liability for breach of contract and other clauses, so as to avoid legal disputes caused by unclear internal rights and responsibilities.

In addition, if it involves international L/C settlement, the identity of entities will lead to excessively high correlation between the "beneficiary" and the "applicant" of the L/C, which will be identified as a soft clause L/C by overseas banks, refusing to pay the payment, and triggering trade disputes. It is recommended to clearly mark "self-operated import agency" in the L/C, and issue a letter of guarantee by a third-party bank to ensure transaction security.

Cindy Chen
Cindy ChenYears of service:3Customer Rating:5.0

Key Account ManagerStart a Chat

From the perspective of on-site customs inspection, when the importer and agent are the same company, it is necessary to prepare relevant supporting materials in advance to cope with the inspection. If the customs triggers verification on site, it is necessary to provide agency agreement, financial accounting vouchers, cargo ownership transfer records and other materials at the first time to prove the authenticity and compliance of the business.

In addition, if the goods involve statutory inspection, the identity of entities will lead the inspection and quarantine authority to identify it as "self-inspection and self-declaration", increasing the inspection ratio from the conventional 5% to more than 30%, and extending the customs clearance time by 2-3 days. It is recommended to submit the Explanatory Statement on Self-inspection of Import Agency to the inspection and quarantine authority before declaration, and make an appointment for inspection in advance to shorten the inspection waiting time.

Daniel Xu
Daniel XuYears of service:10Customer Rating:5.0

Director of Import & Export OperationsStart a Chat

From the perspective of cargo transportation packaging compliance, when the importer and agent are the same company, it is necessary to focus on the consistency of packaging documents. Under the import agency mode, packaging documents (such as MSDS, UN packaging certificate) are usually reviewed by the agent, but when the entities are identical, it is necessary to ensure that the shipper and consignee on the packaging documents are consistent with the importer information on the customs declaration form.

If the information does not match, the customs will determine it as false declaration, requiring re-adjustment of packaging, resulting in additional packaging rectification fees and port detention charges. In addition, when it comes to the import of dangerous goods, the identity of entities will lead to increased verification of packaging compliance.

If the packaging does not meet the standards, the goods will be directly returned overseas, resulting in high return costs. It is recommended to entrust a third-party packaging testing institution to conduct pre-testing to ensure packaging compliance.

Victor Sun
Victor SunYears of service:5Customer Rating:5.0

Trade Risk Control ManagerStart a Chat

From the perspective of tax compliance and document management, when the importer and agent are the same company, it is necessary to strictly distinguish the documents and accounts of import business and agency business. Even for the same company, it is necessary to establish a separate account for agency business, and retain documents such as agency agreement, import contract, foreign exchange payment voucher, customs declaration form to ensure the complete document chain.

If there is no separate accounting, the tax authority will determine it as mixed sales, and the enterprise cannot enjoy the VAT difference taxation policy for agency business, resulting in 5%-10% more VAT paid by the enterprise. In addition, if it involves export to domestic sales business, the identity of entities will lead to the invalidation of tax refund vouchers, and the enterprise cannot apply for export tax refund, resulting in profit loss. It is recommended to entrust a third-party audit institution to conduct document compliance audit every year.

Andy Guo
Andy GuoYears of service:3Customer Rating:5.0

Supply Chain Management ExpertStart a Chat

From the perspective of supply chain structure optimization, when the importer and agent are the same company, it is necessary to sort out the supply chain cost accounting model again. Usually under the import agency mode, the agency fee can be included in the supply chain cost for deduction, but when the entities are identical, the agency fee and import cost shall be accounted for separately, so as to avoid the distortion of supply chain cost calculation caused by cost confusion. In addition, the identity of entities will reduce the flexibility of the supply chain.

If there is a customs supervision risk, it is impossible to isolate the risk by switching agents, leading to the stagnation of the whole supply chain. It is recommended to establish a "virtual agency" mechanism. Even for the same entity, it is necessary to set up an independent agency business module, which is accounted for separately from the import business module, to improve the anti-risk ability of the supply chain.

Note: We respect all users' expressions; however, user comments represent their personal views only.