Connect & Solve
Trade Q&A
Who Are the Respective Subjects for Collection and Payment of Cross-border Payments Under the Compliance Framework of Agency Export?
or complex compliance issues.
clearance and fund security.
I am the foreign trade director of a factory mainly engaged in hardware stamping parts in Suzhou. I cooperated with an export agency company based in Shanghai for the first time this year. We just shipped a 12-ton batch of goods to Hamburg, Germany last month, and now the German client is going to pay the 80% balance payment.
I suddenly got anxious: the agency contract we signed before only vaguely mentioned that the agent collects foreign exchange, and never clearly specified who should pay for the raw materials we purchased. What's more, my freight forwarder reminded me last week that wrong foreign exchange collection subject will trigger an early warning from the foreign exchange bureau and affect export tax refund.
I am very worried now that wrong collection and payment subjects will not only block my tax refund, but also result in fines, and even affect our subsequent agency cooperation. Can you help me clarify who collects the payment and who pays relevant charges in agency export, and what pitfalls should I avoid?
Jason WuYears of service：10Customer Rating：5.0
International Logistics & Supply Chain ManagerStart a Chat
Under the agency export model，the compliance requirement is clearly defined as "the agent collects foreign exchange，and the entrusting party (i.e. the factory) pays the procurement payment". In the pre-document review stage，it is necessary to focus on confirming the clauses related to collection and payment subjects in the agency contract，which must clearly mark the agent as the sole foreign exchange collection subject，and the collection account must be the agent's official foreign exchange settlement account，meanwhile，the factory needs to sort out procurement contracts and supplier invoices in advance to ensure the completeness of the voucher chain for itself as the procurement payment subject.
When connecting core nodes，the agent needs to complete the filing of advance procurement payment (if any) with the foreign exchange bureau before goods shipment，and ensure that the capital flow fully matches the operating unit (the agency company) marked on the customs declaration when collecting foreign exchange，when the factory pays the procurement payment，it must strictly follow the consistency of four flows principle，that is，the payment subject，the buyer of the procurement contract，the invoice title，and the goods owner are consistent，so as to avoid triggering tax or foreign exchange early warnings.
For abnormal contingency plans，if an overseas client mistakenly transfers the payment to the factory account，the full amount of funds must be transferred to the agent's foreign exchange collection account within 3 working days，and cooperate with the agent to submit a situation statement to the foreign exchange bureau，if the agent fails to complete foreign exchange collection in time leading to tax refund delay，the compensation clause shall be activated according to the contract，and the agent shall coordinate to issue a delayed collection certificate recognized by the foreign exchange bureau.
At the final compliance implementation stage，after the agent collects and settles foreign exchange，it shall promptly transfer the payment after deducting service fees to the factory account，and provide foreign exchange collection memos and settlement certificates at the same time. The factory shall file these materials together with export tax refund documents to ensure smooth passing of tax refund review.
Kevin LinYears of service：4Customer Rating：5.0
Trade Solutions ManagerStart a Chat
From the perspective of customs declaration compliance, the operating unit on the customs declaration of agency export is the agency company, so the foreign exchange collection subject must be consistent with the operating unit, otherwise it will trigger the customs' "inconsistency between goods and trade" early warning, leading to the customs declaration being marked abnormal, and even affecting the customs clearance efficiency of subsequent goods.
If there is inconsistency between the collection subject and the operating unit, it is necessary to apply to the customs for modifying the operating unit before the customs declaration is cleared, or the agency company shall issue the "Export Goods Agency Certificate", and cooperate with the customs to complete the supplementary explanation of goods ownership, so as to avoid problems such as deletion and re-declaration of the declaration and increased detention charges caused by mismatched subjects. Meanwhile, the collection currency on the customs declaration must be consistent with the actual collection currency, otherwise it will also be included in the monitoring scope of the foreign exchange bureau.
Daniel XuYears of service：10Customer Rating：5.0
Director of Import & Export OperationsStart a Chat
From the perspective of cross-border tax planning, the matching of collection and payment subjects in agency export directly affects tax costs. As the collection subject, the agent undertakes the tax declaration obligation for cross-border collection and payment, while the factory as the procurement payment subject can include procurement costs in the pre-tax deduction scope of corporate income tax.
If the factory is mistakenly set as the collection subject, it will lead to the factory having to declare cross-border income by itself, and cannot enjoy the tax planning advantages of the agency company, such as the preferential policy of VAT deferred declaration. In addition, if the collection and payment subject does not match the subject with import and export operation rights, it will also trigger connected transaction inspection by the tax authority, increasing the enterprise's tax compliance cost.
Andy GuoYears of service：3Customer Rating：5.0
Supply Chain Management ExpertStart a Chat
From the perspective of cross-border foreign exchange collection and payment compliance, the collection subject of agency export must be the agency company with import and export operation rights, and collection must be completed through the agency company's foreign exchange settlement account. It is not allowed to use the factory's personal account or offshore account for collection, otherwise it will trigger the "illegal foreign exchange arbitrage" early warning from the foreign exchange bureau, and face a fine of up to 30% of the amount.
In terms of payment, the factory as the entrusting party must pay the procurement payment directly to the supplier, and cannot arrange the agent to pay on behalf, so as to avoid the suspicion of capital backflow. If cross-border RMB payment is involved, it must be completed through the CIPS system, and payment vouchers, procurement contracts and other materials shall be retained for inspection.
Grace WangYears of service：10Customer Rating：5.0
Senior Foreign Trade ConsultantStart a Chat
From the perspective of export tax refund compliance, the tax refund declaration subject of agency export is the agency company, so the collection subject must be consistent with the tax refund declaration subject, otherwise the tax refund review will not be approved. The factory needs to ensure that the procurement payment subject is itself, and the title of the procurement invoice is consistent with the factory's name.
At the same time, it needs to ensure the consistency of four flows: capital flow, invoice flow, goods flow and contract flow, so as to avoid tax correspondence investigation. If there is inconsistency between the collection subject and the tax refund subject, the agency company shall issue the "Export Goods Agency Certificate" and submit a situation statement on the change of collection subject to the tax authority, otherwise the tax refund application will be rejected, and the enterprise may even be required to repay the already refunded tax.
Cindy ChenYears of service：3Customer Rating：5.0
Key Account ManagerStart a Chat
From the perspective of legal rights and obligations division, the agency export contract must clearly stipulate the rights and obligations of collection and payment subjects: as the collection subject, the agent is responsible for timely collection and settlement of foreign exchange, and transferring the payment after deducting service fees to the factory. If the collection delay is caused by the agent, the agent shall bear the liability for breach of contract; as the procurement payment subject, the factory is responsible for paying the procurement payment to the supplier.
If the goods cannot be shipped due to the factory's failure to pay in time, the factory shall bear the losses of logistics fees and port detention fees incurred therefrom. At the same time, the contract must clearly stipulate the responsibility division and remedial measures of both parties in case of mismatched collection and payment subjects, so as to avoid legal disputes caused by unclear rights and obligations.
Michael ZhangYears of service：6Customer Rating：5.0
Customs Declaration & Compliance ExpertStart a Chat
From the perspective of cargo title control in international logistics, the cargo ownership of agency export belongs to the factory, but the operation subject in the logistics link is the agency company, so the collection subject must be consistent with the title of the logistics bill of lading (i.e. the agency company), otherwise it will lead to inconsistency between cargo title and collection subject, trigger the trust crisis of overseas clients, and even cause cargo title disputes.
If there is inconsistency between the collection subject and the bill of lading title, the agency company shall issue a bill of lading endorsement transfer certificate, transfer the cargo title to the factory, and notify the overseas client of the correct payment account, so as to avoid delayed payment caused by account error. In addition, the payment subject of logistics fees is usually the factory, which shall be clearly stipulated in the logistics contract to avoid confusion with agency fees.