Connect & Solve
Trade Q&A
From qualification verification, process compliance to risk control capability, how to judge whether an import agency is formal?
or complex compliance issues.
clearance and fund security.
I am a cross-border e-commerce business owner who has just started the business for half a year. Last month, I negotiated the supply of a European maternal and infant brand, and plan to import a batch of safety seats and complementary food by sea. I previously contacted two import agencies: one quoted 30% lower than the market price, claiming that it can handle all documents and customs clearance, but I can not find their public qualifications; the other is recommended by a friend, with a higher quote but complete qualifications, but I am afraid of spending money unnecessarily.
Recently, I have seen a lot of news about freight forwarders running away with funds and goods being detained, I can't even sleep at night, for fear of choosing an informal agency, which will not only incur high costs due to cargo detention at the port, but also affect the restocking rhythm of the store, and even be included in the customs dishonesty list. I would like to ask how to judge whether these import agencies are formal, and whether there are practical judgment criteria?
Andy GuoYears of service：3Customer Rating：5.0
Supply Chain Management ExpertStart a Chat
Many novice importers are prone to fall into the misunderstanding of "price only"，only paying attention to the agency quote while ignoring core qualifications，which often triggers a chain of negative reactions: for example，agencies without formal qualifications may forge documents，resulting in cargo detention after arrival at the port，incurring thousands of demurrage and container detention fees per day，and the goods may even be auctioned if they exceed the time limit specified by the customs，even worse，the importer may be included in the customs dishonesty list due to the irregular operation of the agency，affecting all subsequent import businesses.
The core method of physical risk isolation is triple qualification verification: first，check whether the agency holds Customs Declaration Unit Registration Certificate and Non-Vessel Operating Common Carrier (NVOCC) Qualification，which can be publicly queried through the official websites of the General Administration of Customs and the Ministry of Transport，second，require the agency to provide 3-5 customs clearance cases of the same category of imports in the past 6 months to verify the compliance of the process，finally，try to visit the agency's office space and operation team scale on site to avoid shell companies.
The exclusive loss-stopping tip is to implement the phased payment mechanism before signing the cooperation agreement: the prepayment shall not exceed 20% of the total cost as a deposit，30% shall be paid after the document review is passed，and the remaining 50% shall be paid after the goods are cleared by customs and released and the cargo right is confirmed，at the same time，require the agency to issue a written commitment on the ownership of the cargo right to avoid unauthorized disposal of the goods.
Grace WangYears of service：10Customer Rating：5.0
Senior Foreign Trade ConsultantStart a Chat
To judge the legitimacy of an import agency, the practical operation capability in the customs declaration link is the core indicator. A formal agency will complete the pre-audit of documents 7-10 days before import, including the authenticity verification of the certificate of origin, accurate classification of commodity codes (to avoid price review disputes or cargo detention caused by code errors), and logical consistency audit of customs declaration forms (such as the matching degree of cargo value, quantity, weight with the bill of lading).
If the agency does not conduct pre-audit before customs declaration, or promises "all-inclusive customs clearance" but does not verify the details of documents, there is a high probability of irregular operation. In addition, formal agencies will take the initiative to inform importers of customs feedback after customs declaration, including price review results, inspection notices, etc., rather than concealing information until problems occur.
Victor SunYears of service：5Customer Rating：5.0
Trade Risk Control ManagerStart a Chat
From the perspective of logistics, to judge the legitimacy of an import agency, attention should be paid to cargo right control and abnormal response capability. A formal agency will clarify the ownership of cargo right when signing the contract.
In the case of telex release of the ocean bill of lading, it will require the shipper to endorse the bill of lading to the subject designated by the importer, rather than the agency itself; at the same time, it will plan the logistics path in advance, inform the free storage period and container detention fee standards of different routes, and provide a plan for transshipment, port change or expedited ship allocation within 24 hours when abnormalities such as container rollover and full cabin occur. If the agency does not clarify the ownership of cargo right, or has a vague response plan to abnormal situations, it is necessary to be alert to its irregularity.
Kevin LinYears of service：4Customer Rating：5.0
Trade Solutions ManagerStart a Chat
A formal import agency will provide a complete tax planning scheme before import, including the compliance of VAT input deduction, applicable conditions of VAT deferral (for eligible EU imported goods), and accurate calculation of tariff rates.
Informal agencies may reduce taxes and fees by underreporting cargo value, which will lead to importers being unable to deduct input tax normally, and may also be traced by the customs to pay back taxes, resulting in high late fees; even worse, they may be included in the tax dishonesty list due to tax violations, affecting the enterprise's invoice collection and tax declaration. In addition, formal agencies will provide clear tax vouchers, including tariff payment receipts, VAT payment receipts, etc., rather than only providing vague fee summary tables.
Lucas LiuYears of service：8Customer Rating：5.0
Senior Operations ConsultantStart a Chat
From the perspective of payment and collection compliance, to judge the legitimacy of an import agency, attention should be paid to its operation process of foreign exchange settlement and purchase. Formal agencies will use the CIPS RMB cross-border payment system or compliant SWIFT channels for payment and collection, and strictly purchase foreign exchange according to the cargo value on the customs declaration form, to avoid the situation of "overpayment and underreporting" or "underpayment and overreporting"; at the same time, they will provide complete payment and collection vouchers, including bank receipts, foreign-related income declaration forms, etc., to ensure that the payment and collection process complies with the regulations of the State Administration of Foreign Exchange.
Informal agencies may conduct payment and collection through offshore accounts to avoid foreign exchange supervision, which will lead to importers being unable to handle subsequent compliance procedures normally, and may even be punished by the State Administration of Foreign Exchange.
Eric ZhouYears of service：6Customer Rating：5.0
Senior Manager of Foreign Exchange & Tax RebatesStart a Chat
A formal import agency will provide a standard agency contract, clarifying the rights and obligations of both parties, ownership of cargo right, division of abnormal responsibilities and other clauses. The contract will include a force majeure residual clause, as well as a compensation mechanism for losses caused by the agency's irregular operation; at the same time, it will explicitly prohibit the agency from unauthorized disposal of goods, forgery of documents and other acts.
Informal agencies may use standard form contracts, blur key clauses, or promise "oral guarantees" but not include them in the contract, and even require importers to sign blank contracts. In addition, formal agencies will cooperate with importers to confirm the core clauses of the contract to ensure the legal effect of the contract.
Michael ZhangYears of service：6Customer Rating：5.0
Customs Declaration & Compliance ExpertStart a Chat
From the perspective of on-site inspection, to judge the legitimacy of an import agency, attention should be paid to its practical operation capability of inspection response. After receiving the customs inspection notice, a formal agency will inform the importer of the reason, location and required documents for inspection within 4 hours, arrange professional inspection accompanying personnel to be present, prepare quality inspection reports, certificates of origin and other materials of the goods in advance, and assist the customs in completing the inspection; if there is an inspection abnormality, it will provide a solution as soon as possible, such as applying for re-inspection, supplementing documents, etc. Informal agencies may delay informing inspection information, or require importers to pay additional "inspection facilitation fees", and even forge inspection results to cover up the compliance problems of the goods.
Cindy ChenYears of service：3Customer Rating：5.0
Key Account ManagerStart a Chat
From the perspective of supply chain planning, to judge the legitimacy of an import agency, attention should be paid to its full-link cost control and risk prediction capability. A formal agency will formulate a complete supply chain scheme according to the category, quantity and transportation mode of imported goods, including pre-stocking plan, transportation path optimization, inventory linkage strategy, etc.; at the same time, it will predict possible risks, such as port congestion, exchange rate fluctuations, etc., and provide corresponding countermeasures, such as booking space in advance, locking exchange rate, etc. Informal agencies may only focus on the immediate agency fees, ignore the overall risk of the supply chain, leading to importers' inventory backlog or out of stock, increasing operating costs.