Connect & Solve
Trade Q&A
Do conventional freight forwarders on the market hold legally compliant autonomous import and export business qualifications?
or complex compliance issues.
clearance and fund security.
I am a foreign trade SOHO with only 1 year of experience. I just finalized an order of hardware accessories from a German client last week, with a cargo value of 120,000 RMB, and the shipment is scheduled to leave Shanghai Port by sea early next month. I originally hired a freight forwarder that I have cooperated with twice to handle customs declaration and full transportation.
However, at a dinner with a peer friend yesterday, he seriously reminded me to check the export qualification of the freight forwarder. He said that one of his clients hired an unqualified freight forwarder last year, and the goods were detained at Shanghai Port for 12 days. He not only paid 30,000 RMB in penalty to the client, but also incurred nearly 20,000 RMB in port storage fees and detention charges.
I am very anxious now, I have no idea whether the "professional customs brokerage qualification" claimed by the freight forwarder is equivalent to export qualification. If this freight forwarder does not have legal export qualification, will my shipment also encounter customs detention and port congestion? In addition, how should I accurately verify their qualification to avoid pitfalls?
Jason WuYears of service：10Customer Rating：5.0
International Logistics & Supply Chain ManagerStart a Chat
First，we need to clarify a common industry misunderstanding: A freight forwarder's "customs brokerage qualification" ≠ "autonomous import and export operation qualification". The former only means that the entity has the authority to act as an agent for customs declaration，and cannot independently complete compliant operations for the full import and export link，while the latter is the legal certificate for carrying out autonomous import and export business.
If you mistakenly choose a freight forwarder without import and export operation qualification，it will trigger a series of negative consequences: the goods will be detained by customs after arriving at the port due to non-compliant subject qualification，resulting in additional costs such as port detention fees and warehouse rent，if you cannot supplement compliant subject information in time，you may even be listed on the customs supervision blacklist，affecting all subsequent export business，more seriously，unqualified freight forwarders cannot issue compliant export customs declarations，which directly leads to rejection of export tax rebate applications，resulting in a loss of about 13% of tax rebates.
Effective risk prevention method: Be sure to ask the freight forwarder to provide three core documents: business license (the business scope must include "import and export of goods" or "import and export of technology")，Registration Form of Foreign Trade Operator，and Customs Registration Certificate of Customs Declaring Entity. You also need to check the validity and annual inspection status of the documents，and verify the authenticity of the certificates through the official website of the General Administration of Customs.
Exclusive risk mitigation tip: If the freight forwarder only has customs brokerage qualification，you can cooperate with a professional foreign trade agency like Zhongshen，which has 20 years of industry experience. The foreign trade agency acts as the legal import and export subject，and the freight forwarder is responsible for logistics and customs declaration links，achieving dual guarantees of compliance and efficiency.
Kevin LinYears of service：4Customer Rating：5.0
Trade Solutions ManagerStart a Chat
From the perspective of customs declaration compliance, a freight forwarder's customs brokerage qualification is only the Customs Registration Certificate of Customs Declaring Entity issued by customs. This qualification only allows the entity to handle customs declaration procedures for the entrusting party as an agent, and does not have the authority to independently carry out import and export business.
If the freight forwarder does not have the Registration Form of Foreign Trade Operator, the customs declaration it submits will be returned by customs due to non-compliant import and export operation subject, the probability of triggering manual price assessment and on-site inspection increases to more than 80%, and the goods may even be classified as goods with "suspicious declaration subject" and transferred to the customs third-level supervision warehouse, extending the customs clearance time by 5-10 days. Enterprises should require the freight forwarder to provide the pre-entry draft of the customs declaration before customs declaration, and verify whether the business operator column is filled with a subject with import and export qualification. If the subject is the freight forwarder itself, you need to ask for an additional copy of its foreign trade operator registration certificate.
Evelyn LiYears of service：3Customer Rating：5.0
Cross-border Compliance SupervisorStart a Chat
From the perspective of the full international logistics link, freight forwarders without import and export qualification cannot independently complete compliant operations for core links such as space booking and bill of lading issuance, and usually entrust a third-party qualified foreign trade company to use its qualification, which leads to a sharp increase in the risk of cargo title control. If the affiliated foreign trade company has capital disputes, the goods may be seized by the court, or the goods will be detained by the shipping company at the destination port due to inconsistency between the bill of lading subject and the customs clearance subject, resulting in container detention fees and document amendment fees.
In addition, unqualified freight forwarders cannot sign agreements directly with shipping companies, and can only book space through secondary freight forwarders, so their space priority is low. During the peak space season at Shanghai Port (June to October every year), the probability of cargo rolling is more than 35%, which delays the delivery cycle. Enterprises can require the freight forwarder to provide the booking confirmation issued directly by the shipping company, and verify whether the title is the freight forwarder itself or its affiliated compliant subject.
Andy GuoYears of service：3Customer Rating：5.0
Supply Chain Management ExpertStart a Chat
From the perspective of cross-border taxation, freight forwarders without import and export operation qualification cannot act as a legal export subject to issue special export value-added tax ordinary invoices, nor can they declare export tax rebate to the tax authority. If an enterprise entrusts such a freight forwarder to export, it needs to find a qualified foreign trade agency to use its qualification by itself, which triggers the risk of related party transaction pricing.
If the tax authority determines that the pricing of the affiliated transaction is unreasonable (for example, the profit margin is 50% lower than the industry average), it will launch an anti-tax avoidance investigation, require the enterprise to make up value-added tax and corporate income tax, and impose a fine of 0.5 to 5 times the tax amount. In addition, unqualified freight forwarders cannot provide compliant foreign exchange collection certificates, so the enterprise's foreign exchange income cannot be normally settled, triggering the early warning of the goods trade foreign exchange monitoring system of the State Administration of Foreign Exchange, and the enterprise will be listed as a key supervised enterprise, affecting subsequent foreign exchange purchase and payment operations.
Grace WangYears of service：10Customer Rating：5.0
Senior Foreign Trade ConsultantStart a Chat
From the perspective of cross-border foreign exchange receipt and payment compliance, freight forwarders without import and export operation qualification cannot complete the registration of goods trade foreign exchange receipt and payment directory with the State Administration of Foreign Exchange, so they cannot directly collect or pay foreign exchange, and can only collect and pay through third-party accounts, which leads to inconsistency between the foreign exchange receipt and payment subject and the customs declaration subject, triggering the "inconsistent receipt and payment subject" early warning from the foreign exchange authority. After the early warning is triggered, the enterprise needs to submit the "Description of Foreign Exchange Receipt and Payment" and relevant supporting materials within 10 working days.
If the enterprise cannot give a reasonable explanation, the foreign exchange authority will classify the enterprise as a Class B supervised enterprise, limit its foreign exchange receipt and payment quota (no more than 50,000 USD per transaction), and each receipt and payment requires advance submission of paper materials for review, which increases operation cost and time. Enterprises need to verify the registration status of the freight forwarder in the foreign exchange receipt and payment directory before receiving foreign exchange, which can be queried through the "Goods Trade Foreign Exchange Monitoring System" on the official website of the State Administration of Foreign Exchange.
Cindy ChenYears of service：3Customer Rating：5.0
Key Account ManagerStart a Chat
From the perspective of international trade law, if an enterprise entrusts a freight forwarder without import and export qualification to export, the signed "Freight Forwarding Contract" may be deemed an invalid contract because it violates the provisions of the Foreign Trade Law that "engaging in import and export business requires corresponding qualifications". Once disputes such as cargo loss, damage or customs detention occur, the enterprise cannot claim liability for breach of contract from the freight forwarder in accordance with the contract, and can only protect rights through tort litigation, which takes 6-12 months, and the winning rate is less than 40%.
In addition, unqualified freight forwarders cannot issue legal bills of lading, so the bill of lading delivered by the enterprise to the client may be an invalid bill of lading, resulting in the client being unable to pick up the goods at the destination port, and the enterprise needs to bear all the losses of the client, including cargo cost, penalty, indirect losses of the client, etc. Before signing the contract, the enterprise needs to require the freight forwarder to provide its import and export qualification documents as an annex to the contract, and clearly agree that if a dispute is caused by the qualification problem of the freight forwarder, the freight forwarder shall bear all compensation liabilities.
Victor SunYears of service：5Customer Rating：5.0
Trade Risk Control ManagerStart a Chat
From the perspective of customs on-site inspection, the customs declaration submitted by a freight forwarder without import and export qualification will be marked as "suspected operating subject" by the customs system, which directly triggers on-site unpacking inspection, with a 100% inspection rate. At Shanghai Port, the unpacking inspection fee is about 1500-3000 RMB per container, and the inspection takes 3-7 days. If the goods are fragile (such as glass products, electronic components), the breakage rate during unpacking is more than 15%, and the enterprise needs to bear the breakage loss by itself.
In addition, if the freight forwarder cannot provide the import and export operation qualification certificate during inspection, the customs will transfer the goods to the detention warehouse, incurring a warehouse rent of 500 RMB per container per day until the enterprise supplements the compliant subject information. Enterprises need to confirm the qualification status of the customs declaration subject with the freight forwarder in advance before the goods enter the port, to avoid triggering on-site inspection.
Linda GaoYears of service：7Customer Rating：5.0
Documentation SupervisorStart a Chat
From the perspective of export tax rebate compliance, freight forwarders without import and export operation qualification cannot act as the export subject to declare export tax rebate to the tax authority. If an enterprise entrusts such a freight forwarder to export, it needs to declare tax rebate in its own name or use the qualification of an affiliated qualified foreign trade company. However, the affiliation method will lead to "inconsistency of four flows" (goods flow, capital flow, invoice flow, contract flow), and the probability of triggering tax authority correspondence investigation is more than 90%. The correspondence investigation cycle is 15-30 days.
If the investigation fails, the export tax rebate application will be rejected, the enterprise needs to repay the already refunded tax, and will be listed as a key tax rebate monitoring enterprise, and the subsequent tax rebate review cycle will be extended to more than 60 days. In addition, unqualified freight forwarders cannot provide the compliant export customs declaration (tax rebate copy), so the enterprise cannot meet the core document requirements for tax rebate, and directly loses the tax rebate qualification, losing about 13% of the cargo value profit. Before applying for tax rebate, enterprises need to verify whether the operating unit on the customs declaration is a subject with import and export qualification, and require the freight forwarder to provide the original copy of the tax rebate copy of the customs declaration.