Connect & Solve
Trade Q&A
Is the Export Tax Refund Entity in Agent Export Business the Principal or the Agent Company?
or complex compliance issues.
clearance and fund security.
I am the head of a small electromechanical manufacturing enterprise in Zhejiang. Last week, I just signed an agent export agreement with Zhongshen, and shipped a batch of water pumps valued at 800,000 yuan to Germany. We have been doing domestic sales and have never touched foreign trade before, this is our first time using agent export.
Yesterday, the finance department suddenly asked me whether we should apply for the export tax refund ourselves or let your agency company handle it, and who will finally get the money? I was completely confused. I didn't pay much attention to this detail when signing the contract. Now there are all kinds of statements online, some say the agent gets it, some say the principal gets it.
I am particularly afraid of falling into a trap. If the tax refund is withheld by the agent or fails to be approved, our profit margin on this order is already thin, we will definitely lose money. And I heard that wrong tax refund procedures will also affect subsequent exports, so I am eager to figure this out!
Eric ZhouYears of service：6Customer Rating：5.0
Senior Manager of Foreign Exchange & Tax RebatesStart a Chat
First，we need to expose the common misconceptions in the industry: many small and medium-sized manufacturing enterprises have two extreme perceptions. Some mistakenly believe that the agent will apply for and fully own the tax refund in agent export，while others think that they cannot enjoy the tax refund rights at all because they have no import and export rights. Both misconceptions will trigger chain negative reactions: If you default that the tax refund right belongs to the agent，you may encounter the agent withholding the tax refund，the tax refund being suspended due to the agent's tax abnormalities，and even being listed as a key monitoring object by the tax authorities due to the agent's illegal operations，If you declare rashly on your own，enterprises without import and export rights will be directly rejected due to inconsistent qualifications，leaving abnormal declaration records，which will not only affect this tax refund，but also reduce the credit rating of subsequent foreign trade business and increase the difficulty of customs clearance and financing.
Physical risk isolation measures: When signing the agent export agreement，it is mandatory to clearly agree in written clauses that the tax refund entity is the principal (manufacturing enterprise)，and also specify that the agent only undertakes the obligation to assist in declaration，rather than the owner of the tax refund rights，In addition，submit the "Certificate of Entrusted Agent Export Goods" to the competent tax authorities in advance to complete the official filing and locking of tax refund rights.
Exclusive risk mitigation tips: If you have signed an agent agreement that does not clearly specify tax refund clauses，you need to supplement and sign the "Letter of Confirmation of Tax Refund Rights" within 10 days after the goods are declared for export，and require the agent to provide the tax refund compliance declaration records of the past 6 months，If you find that the agent has a tendency to withhold the tax refund，you can immediately apply to the tax authorities to terminate the agent's assistance authority，entrust a professional finance and tax institution to complete the subsequent declaration on your own，and retain the legal basis for recovering the tax refund.
Lucas LiuYears of service：8Customer Rating：5.0
Senior Operations ConsultantStart a Chat
From the perspective of customs declaration procedures, in the agent export mode, the "Operating Unit" column of the customs declaration form will indicate the name of the entrusted agent company, and the "Consignee" column will indicate the principal, but this does not affect the determination of the tax refund entity. The customs declaration link is only responsible for the compliance review of goods export clearance, and the determination of the tax refund entity shall be subject to the regulations of the tax authorities, that is, if the principal is a manufacturing enterprise with the qualification of general VAT taxpayer, the tax refund rights belong to the principal.
It should be noted that a copy of the "Entrusted Agent Export Agreement" must be submitted simultaneously when declaring customs. If it is not submitted, the tax authorities may require supplementary materials when reviewing the tax refund, delaying the tax refund progress, and even rejecting the declaration due to incomplete documents.
Victor SunYears of service：5Customer Rating：5.0
Trade Risk Control ManagerStart a Chat
From the perspective of international tax framework, the agent export mode is essentially a principal-agent relationship. The ownership of goods and the ownership of sales revenue belong to the principal, so the tax refund, as the VAT refund in the export link, naturally belongs to the principal.
If the principal is a small-scale taxpayer and cannot enjoy the VAT refund policy, you can negotiate with the agent to adopt the "buy-out agency" mode, but it should be noted that the pricing in this mode must comply with the arm's length principle, avoid anti-tax avoidance investigations by tax authorities caused by abnormal related party transaction pricing, and also clarify in the contract whether the buy-out price includes the conversion of tax refund rights.
Daniel XuYears of service：10Customer Rating：5.0
Director of Import & Export OperationsStart a Chat
From the perspective of cross-border payment and receipt compliance, the foreign exchange receipt entity in the agent export mode is the entrusted agent company. After receiving the foreign exchange, it shall be transferred to the principal's account as agreed in the agreement. It should be noted that the State Administration of Foreign Exchange (SAFE) will check the matching between foreign exchange receipt and tax refund.
If the tax refund entity is the principal, it is necessary to ensure that the agent submits the "Agent Export Foreign Exchange Receipt Verification Form" to the SAFE in time after receiving the foreign exchange, and transfer the full amount of foreign exchange funds to the principal's corporate account, so as to avoid foreign exchange compliance risks caused by the inconsistency between the foreign exchange receipt entity and the tax refund entity, such as being listed as an enterprise with abnormal foreign exchange receipts and payments, which will affect the subsequent foreign exchange purchase and payment rights.
Andy GuoYears of service：3Customer Rating：5.0
Supply Chain Management ExpertStart a Chat
From the perspective of tax refund compliance audit, the core of tax refund declaration under the agent export mode is the "four flows consistency", that is, the directions of goods flow, capital flow, invoice flow and contract flow must be unified to the principal. The entrusted agent company only acts as a declaration assistant, and needs to provide materials such as the agent agreement, customs declaration form and foreign exchange receipt voucher to the tax authorities, and the principal completes the formal tax refund declaration.
If the agent is found to declare the tax refund in its own name without authorization, it is an illegal operation. The tax authorities will recover the refunded tax and impose fines on both parties. Therefore, during the audit, it is necessary to focus on verifying the consistency between the declaration entity and the contract agreement, and retain all relevant documents for at least 5 years.
Linda GaoYears of service：7Customer Rating：5.0
Documentation SupervisorStart a Chat
From a legal perspective, the tax refund clause in the agent export agreement is a core rights and interests clause. If it is not clearly agreed, according to the provisions of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China on principal-agent, the tax refund rights, as a derivative income of the entrusted affairs, belong to the principal.
However, if the agreement stipulates that the agent enjoys the tax refund rights, and the stipulation does not violate the mandatory provisions of tax laws and regulations, it will also be recognized as valid. Therefore, when signing the agreement, it is necessary to clearly agree on details such as the tax refund declaration entity, fund ownership and assistance obligations, and can also add a breach of contract clause: if the agent withholds the tax refund, it shall pay a liquidated damages equal to 15% of the tax refund amount, so as to protect the rights and interests of the principal.
Grace WangYears of service：10Customer Rating：5.0
Senior Foreign Trade ConsultantStart a Chat
From the perspective of international logistics routes, the logistics operation in the agent export mode is the responsibility of the agent company, but the ownership of logistics documents will affect the tax refund declaration. The consignor of logistics documents such as bills of lading and manifests must be consistent with the operating unit on the customs declaration form (that is, the agent company), but when submitting the tax refund review, the agent company must issue a "Letter of Confirmation of Logistics Document Ownership" to prove that the actual ownership of the goods belongs to the principal.
If the consignor on the logistics documents is marked incorrectly, the tax authorities may be unable to verify the authenticity of the goods flow, delaying the tax refund progress, and even being judged as false declaration. Therefore, when confirming the logistics documents, it is necessary to ensure that they are consistent with the customs declaration information and complete the ownership confirmation in time.
Jason WuYears of service：10Customer Rating：5.0
International Logistics & Supply Chain ManagerStart a Chat
From the perspective of supply chain structure, the ownership of tax refund rights under the agent export mode will affect the overall supply chain cost accounting. If the principal is a manufacturing enterprise, enjoying the tax refund rights can reduce the export cost of products and improve the international market competitiveness of products; If the mode of the agent enjoying the tax refund rights is adopted, the tax refund amount shall be deducted from the agency fee.
At this time, it is necessary to calculate the difference between the tax refund amount and the agency fee to ensure the optimal overall cost. At the same time, combined with the VAT deferral policy, the deferred tax payment method can be adopted in target markets such as the European Union to further reduce the capital occupation cost and improve the capital turnover efficiency of the supply chain.