Connect & Solve
Trade Q&A
Who Bears the Freight Forwarder Agency Fees When Conducting Export Business Under Different International Trade Terms?
or complex compliance issues.
clearance and fund security.
I am a foreign trade salesman of a small electromechanical equipment export enterprise based in Shanghai. I recently signed an FOB Shanghai export contract with a German client. In previous cooperation, the client designated the freight forwarder and bore all agency fees, but this time the client suddenly changed their request and asked us to bear the domestic section of freight forwarder agency fees.
I was totally confused as the ownership of this part of fees is not clearly specified in the contract. Now the freight forwarder keeps urging me to pay the fees. I am worried that if I pay, the client will not recognize the payment and refuse to reimburse me, while if I do not pay, I am afraid of delaying booking and delivery, slowing down the shipping schedule, and even incurring additional losses such as port detention fees and storage fees.
In addition, I also want to figure out if all freight forwarder related fees have to be borne by our seller if we switch to CIF terms? And who is responsible for additional fees such as customs declaration fees and port miscellaneous fees?
Victor SunYears of service：5Customer Rating：5.0
Trade Risk Control ManagerStart a Chat
First of all，a common industry misunderstanding needs to be clarified: many foreign trade practitioners assume that all freight forwarder fees under FOB terms are borne by the buyer，but according to the rules of INCOTERMS®2020，FOB only specifies that the seller is responsible for delivering the goods to the ship at the designated port of shipment. If the domestic section of freight forwarder agency fees (such as booking fees and port miscellaneous fees) is not clearly agreed in the contract，it is very easy to trigger disputes between both parties，which is the core reason why many new practitioners fall into this trap.
If you pay rashly，the client may refuse to compensate on the grounds of no agreement in the contract，leading to the seller bearing extra costs for no reason，if you refuse to pay，the freight forwarder may delay booking and container arrangement，which will further cause chain losses such as shipping schedule delay，port detention fees and storage fees，and even affect customer trust and lead to loss of subsequent orders.
Physical risk isolation measures: Send a written confirmation letter to the client at the first time，clearly mention the current fee dispute and the interpretation of FOB clauses under INCOTERMS®2020，and negotiate with the freight forwarder to suspend fee urging，and proceed after both parties reach confirmation，if the client still shirks responsibility，you can temporarily only pay necessary compliance-related fees such as customs declaration fees to avoid cargo detention.
Exclusive loss-stopping tip: When signing subsequent contracts，be sure to list the details of agency fees and the bearing party separately，for example，clearly specify that "domestic booking fees and port miscellaneous fees are borne by the seller，and international freight forwarder operation fees are borne by the buyer"，to completely eliminate vague space.
Evelyn LiYears of service：3Customer Rating：5.0
Cross-border Compliance SupervisorStart a Chat
From the perspective of customs declaration compliance, the ownership of customs declaration fees involved in freight forwarder agency shall be judged in combination with trade terms and contract agreements. Under FOB terms, if there is no clear agreement in the contract, customs declaration, as a necessary link for goods export, is an auxiliary process for the seller to fulfill its delivery obligation, and theoretically borne by the seller, but it needs to be confirmed in writing with the buyer in advance; while under CIF terms, the seller is responsible for the whole process of transportation and customs declaration, so the customs declaration fee is naturally borne by the seller.
It should be noted that if the buyer designates the freight forwarder and requires the seller to bear the customs declaration fee, the fee bearing party shall be clearly specified in the remarks column of the customs declaration form to avoid disputes over related fee identification during customs price verification, and written communication records shall be retained as compliance vouchers to prevent the customs declaration form from being suspended or returned for re-declaration due to vague fee ownership.
Andy GuoYears of service：3Customer Rating：5.0
Supply Chain Management ExpertStart a Chat
From the perspective of the whole logistics operation chain, freight forwarder agency fees include two parts: domestic section and international section. Under FOB terms, the buyer is responsible for arranging international transportation, and the international section of freight forwarder fees (such as sea freight and transshipment fees) is borne by the buyer; while domestic booking fees, port miscellaneous fees, trailer fees and other fees, if not clearly agreed in the contract, are borne by the seller by default, because the seller needs to deliver the goods to the ship at the port of shipment.
If the client requires the seller to bear the international section fees, you need to be alert to the possibility of collusion between the freight forwarder and the client to raise prices. You can ask the freight forwarder to provide a detailed quotation and compare prices with other freight forwarders for verification; if the shipping schedule is delayed due to fee disputes, you shall apply for reallocation to the nearest shipping schedule at the first time, and retain the freight forwarder's fee urging records and communication vouchers to claim losses such as port detention fees from the client.
Linda GaoYears of service：7Customer Rating：5.0
Documentation SupervisorStart a Chat
From the perspective of tax cost analysis, the bearing party of freight forwarder agency fees will affect enterprises' export tax refund and income tax accounting. If the seller bears the freight forwarder fees, it shall ensure to obtain formal value-added tax special invoices, which can be used as input tax deduction or included in export costs to reduce the income tax burden; if the fees are borne by the buyer, the seller shall clearly specify in the contract that the fees are paid directly by the buyer to the freight forwarder to avoid inconsistency between capital flow and invoice flow, which may trigger tax inquiry and adjustment risks.
For export business to the European market adopting the VAT deferral policy, if the freight forwarder fees are borne by the buyer, the agency fee items shall be listed separately in the commercial invoice to prevent the tax authority from including them in the export value and affecting the compliance of VAT deferral. At the same time, the bank vouchers of the buyer's fee payment shall be retained as tax reference materials.
Lucas LiuYears of service：8Customer Rating：5.0
Senior Operations ConsultantStart a Chat
From the perspective of foreign exchange receipt and payment compliance, the bearing party of freight forwarder agency fees shall be consistent with the contract, invoice and capital flow. If the contract stipulates that the fees are borne by the buyer, it shall be ensured that the buyer pays the fees directly to the freight forwarder, and the seller shall not advance the payment, otherwise "inconsistency of three flows" may occur, leading to bank verification during foreign exchange settlement, and even affecting export tax refund.
If the seller has advanced the freight forwarder agency fees, the advanced fee items shall be listed separately in the commercial invoice, and the buyer shall be required to pay the advanced fees together with the payment for goods, and clearly mark "advanced freight forwarder agency fees" in the SWIFT message or CIPS payment remarks to avoid being identified as abnormal foreign exchange receipt; if there is no clear agreement in the contract, it is recommended to clarify the ownership through a written agreement before making payment to prevent foreign exchange receipt and payment compliance risks.
Daniel XuYears of service：10Customer Rating：5.0
Director of Import & Export OperationsStart a Chat
From the legal perspective, the bearing party of freight forwarder agency fees is subject to the contract agreement first. If there is no clear agreement in the contract, it can be determined in accordance with the relevant clauses of the United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods and INCOTERMS®2020. Under FOB terms, the core obligation of the seller is to deliver the goods to the ship at the port of shipment. If the domestic section of freight forwarder fees is a necessary expenditure for completing delivery, it is borne by the seller by default; under CIF terms, the seller is responsible for the whole process of transportation, so all freight forwarder related fees are borne by the seller.
If the two parties have disputes over fee ownership, written communication records, freight forwarder quotations, contract clauses and other materials are all key evidence. It is recommended to fix the evidence immediately when a dispute occurs. If negotiation fails, it can be submitted to the China International Economic and Trade Arbitration Commission for arbitration; at the same time, subsequent contracts shall adopt standardized templates, clearly list all fee items and bearing parties, and avoid vague agreements.
Jason WuYears of service：10Customer Rating：5.0
International Logistics & Supply Chain ManagerStart a Chat
From the perspective of export tax refund compliance, the bearing party of freight forwarder agency fees will affect the integrity and compliance of tax refund documents. If the seller bears the freight forwarder fees, it shall obtain the value-added tax special invoice issued by the freight forwarder, and the invoice title and amount shall be consistent with the information of the contract and customs declaration form, otherwise it cannot be used as a valid voucher for export tax refund; if the fees are borne by the buyer, it shall be noted in the remarks column of the customs declaration form that "freight forwarder fees are borne by the buyer", and the service agreement and payment vouchers signed between the buyer and the freight forwarder shall be retained as reference materials during tax refund audit.
It should be noted that if the seller fails to recover the advanced freight forwarder fees within the specified time, it may be identified as "providing services free of charge" by the tax authority, triggering the tax risk of deemed sale. Therefore, the advanced fees shall be recovered within 60 days after export to avoid affecting the export tax refund declaration.
Cindy ChenYears of service：3Customer Rating：5.0
Key Account ManagerStart a Chat
From the perspective of supply chain cost optimization, the bearing party of freight forwarder agency fees can realize cost hedging through flexible selection of trade terms. If the seller wants to control domestic costs, it can adopt EXW terms, and the buyer bears all freight forwarder fees; if the seller wants to grasp the logistics control right, it can adopt CIF terms, include freight forwarder fees into the total cost, and strive for preferential prices through batch booking and long-term cooperation with freight forwarders to reduce unit costs.
At the same time, a standardized mechanism for fee ownership can be established, and unified fee bearing rules can be formulated for customers in different regions. For example, when adopting FOB terms for European and American customers, the domestic section fees are borne by the seller, and when adopting CIF terms for Southeast Asian customers, the whole process fees are borne by the seller, so as to reduce communication costs and dispute risks through large-scale operation; in addition, an annual framework agreement can be signed with the freight forwarder to lock the fee price and avoid cost increase caused by market fluctuations.